Posted 02 April 2012 - 06:07 PM
I use both Berkley powerbait and Gulp earthworms, only in the natural colour for brookies. They don't seem to go for the orange or pink in my experience. Generally, they seem to like 'em just as much as the real thing. However there are days when I've almost given up then would switch to the real worms, or a spinner or jig, and hook one on the next cast. But hey, that's fishin'. If they aint biting, switch it up or move on up the stream.....
I had a jar of yellow powerbait dough last year, and after an hour of nothing I flicked it in the tackle box. It sat there until August when I discovered that Mackerel absolutely love the stuff, and I never tried troutin with it again.
Now steelhead on the other hand Love the bubblegum pink worms. I landed many last summer back home in PEI with them, and I'm betting the steelhead in Crooked Creek down in Albert County will like them just as much this summer. Watch some youtube vids of the boys fishing steelies on the west coast and you'll see what I mean. They go nuts for the pink, whether its worms or jigs.
The main reason I like artificial worms oppossed to live ones is their re-usability. I'm constantly re-baiting when I use live, whereas I've caught as many as 7 trout using the same artificial. Even if you don't hook up, the fish hitting the live worm tend to tear it to shreds, and though it still may work for a couple of casts, presentation goes out the window.